The scorecard
Every published core claim, its falsifier, its resolve-by date, and the graded resolution. Resolutions are human judgment, recorded in plain view - the longitudinal record is the product.
| Company | Piece | Claim / falsifier | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| collateral_clock | gpus-backing-ai-debt-halve-every-four-years 2026-10-27 | The merchant replacement cost of one H100-equivalent of NVIDIA compute halves every ~49 months (A100 $38,058 Nov-2020 -> B300 $17,019 Aug-2025, per Epoch AI); market-to-replacement multiples split on that clock (CRWV 1.2x vs NBIS 8.9x). Falsifier: (1) Rubin merchant price below ~$12,500/H100e = the clock holds (one half-life after the H100); flat-to-up = slowed. (2) MUSK'S GUPPY CLAIM (Oct 25, verbatim): '200+ neoclouds are going to see guppy-level death and consolidation. Some will make it through, but not many' - scored as consolidation/distress/failure events across the tracked neocloud set by late 2027. Watchpoints: Rubin pricing; second-hand H100 prints; CoreWeave Nov 9 + Nebius Nov 10 earnings; SpaceX 10-Q capital-commitment language on the $40B. resolve by 2027-06-30 | pending |
| orbital | two-stacks-in-orbit 2026-10-20 | The inversion, organizational not silicon: China's orbital compute is real (20 satellites across two launches, the only multi-satellite compute constellation flying) while its silicon opacity dissolves only from the edge (Oct-14 batch named XFEON's StarCore S1; a MetaX GPU flew in July; no Ascend or Cambricon flagship part flies in any compute constellation); the Western constellations are filings (1.14M satellites requested as ceiling counts, all three verified) with merchant silicon announced (NVIDIA's space module) and only a demo satellite plus two hosted Axiom nodes flying. Falsifier: An Ascend or Cambricon part flying in a compute constellation (Cambricon's Feb-2026 investor denial is one side); New Glenn's December return flying or slipping; the FCC ruling on the Sunrise amendment (waiver treatment the tell); SenseTime's four sats and Three-Body's third group by year-end 2026; 2027: first Space.IDC G1, Pearl verification, Starmind first launches, NVIDIA module first flight. resolve by 2027-06-30 | pending |
| terafab | terafab-tax-break-per-job 2026-10-15 | Terafabs eight executed school-tax agreements carry \$1,660.4M of M&O relief through 2046 against the filings own employment figures (617 + 383 = 1,000 direct permanent, the per-phase-vs-cumulative ambiguity flagged) - \$1.66M per filed job; even the most generous reading (4,000) leaves \$415K per job. Falsifier: The 2029 hiring test: Iola schedules all 383 jobs for 2029 and Anderson-Shiro reaches the tax rolls in 2029-30. Hiring materially above 4,000 direct jobs by then, or abandonment/phase slippage before placement, resolves the claim either way. resolve by 2029-12-31 | pending |
| xai | xai-780000-gpus-may-efficiency-number 2026-10-14 | xAI's training MFU was reported at ~11% in early May 2026 (The Information; an internal memo confirmed it, the president calling it 'embarrassingly low') against a reported hyperscaler band in the low-to-mid 40s - IF like-for-like, roughly 4x throughput on the table, with BF16-vs-FP8 and scale caveats. By Oct 7: installed base ~780k per Musk's Sep 25 census (Colossus 2 alone scheduled to 1.21M year-end, last tranche conditional; fleet ~1.44M if it lands); MFU not refreshed since May; the Anthropic tenancy is a documented conflict (S-1: $1.25B/mo through May 2029, 90-day exit vs Musk May 28, a week after the May 21 filing coverage: short-term at SpaceX's request); the hosting book is a forward stack (~$1.4B/mo billed today, ~$3.43B/mo run-rate once the December tranche lands). Falsifier: Any refreshed or disclosed MFU for the current (Blackwell-era) fleet; Nicolls's target was months away, not years. A reading above 25% on a like-for-like definition resolves the fork. resolve by 2027-06-30 | pending |
| terafab | terafab-paperwork-says-spacex 2026-10-12 | Terafabs paperwork names SpaceX, not Tesla: all four registry entities (TERAFAB LLC DE 3913340; TERAFAB TEXAS LLC TX 0806741990; Terafab AI LLC TX 0806598568 at 1 Rocket Rd Starbase; WIT Tech LLC TX 0804854926 Brownsville) carry SpaceWorld addresses and none an Austin one; the S-1/424B4 carries no Terafab dollar figure; the only signable number, the $5B county minimum, has an unsigned SpaceX line. Falsifier: A filing booking Terafab capital (the SPCX Q3 10-Q due around November 2026 is the first candidate), a Tesla 10-K or earnings call booking Terafab capex or naming a Terafab entity, the executed county agreement with a signature on the $5B minimum line, or JETI documents naming applicant entities other than the four on file. resolve by 2027-04-30 | pending |
| tenstorrent | tenstorrent-1-29-billion-filed-no-price 2026-10-08 | Tenstorrent's Aug-2026 raise is the largest capital event in its filed history ($1,286,829,662 to 134 investors) yet carries no price anywhere: the Form D discloses none, the circulating $3.2B is an unclosed Nov-2025 talks figure ($800M, Fidelity-led), and the $108.35 listing price is an indicative model that a vendor (not the filing) turns into a $5.76B implied valuation via an assumed share count. If the talks figure held as pre-money, the filing would represent an undisclosed ~28.7% primary stake - implausible, so the mark moved or the filing aggregates. Falsifier: Any disclosed post-money for the Aug-2026 raise (named round coverage, fund portfolio disclosures, or an S-1). Nearest watchpoints: the monthly Fidelity holdings listings and the registered-fund marks already in the wild -- two Fidelity portfolios carried the same Series D-1 47.6% apart ($75.63 May 31 vs $111.61 Jun 30, per AltStreet); ARK $81.39->$89.42. resolve by 2027-04-30 | confirmed RESOLVED Oct 19: Series E $1.5B at $6.2B post (Bloomberg/Company). The fork falsifier (any disclosed post-money) is MET. The published piece called the gap between the $1.29B Form D (no valuation) and the $3.2B circulating figure; the answer is $6.2B nearly double the talks figure. Napkin: 1500/6200 = 24.2 percent. |
| compute | compute-financing-ledger 2026-10-06 | The committed-vs-graded fork: sellers and a handful of landlords file their compute paper; the tenant-side commitments are mostly unfiled; the utilization spread is the tenant unit-cost problem and the leading walk indicator Falsifier: NVIDIA Q3 guarantee/commitment lines flat or grown (Nov 18); the Anthropic S-1 compute-commitments note; any Stargate-class walk resolve by 2027-01-31 | pending |
| robotics | robot-marks-not-publicly-computable 2026-09-29 | In the robotics sector the multiple measures distance from audit, not quality of the business: ten marks rest on ten different instruments (filed, customer-announced, company-announced, people-sourced, single-aggregator), none audited the same way, and the year's largest round has no public price at all. Falsifier: Any of: audited filings showing the industrial demand the private marks assume (UBTech narrowing to profit, Unitree domain mix shifting from 73.6% research); the Dogotix Dec-31 1,000-IRON/month clock met with the completion 6-K; the Unitree lockup/first secondary print holding the 0B debut; an AgiBot prospectus range underwriting the 35-45x ask on checked books; an Atoms price surfacing by any route. resolve by 2027-03-31 | pending |
| mask | the-bigger-stencil-asml-photomask 2026-09-22 | The photomask layer is the semiconductor chain's newest structural chokepoint -- a merchant tool stack six-tenths Japanese with a two-for-two Japanese blank duopoly -- committed on paper to a 12-inch, 2031/2033 re-tool that its own supply base has not yet subscribed to, while the US's largest merchant shop waits on economics and China's DUV multi-patterning workaround compounds its dependence on the very stack it cannot localize (blanks, writers, actinic inspection, pellicles) under two live export-control perimeters. Falsifier: 2031 pilot or 2033 readiness slips or is abandoned; ASML/TSMC confirm existing High NA tools retrofit to 6x12 (two-format re-tool burden collapses); a second actinic patterned-mask inspection vendor ships at production grade; Samsung's 2028 memory or TSMC's 2030 dated commitment walks back; no named tool-vendor contracts by the 2027 SPIE cycle (the uncommitted-supply-base test); China joins large-format standard-setting, ships production EUV masks, or domestic blank production moves off zero. resolve by 2027-06-30 | pending |
| anthropic | anthropics-543-billion-compute-ledger 2026-09-15 | Anthropic's compute-procurement program, itemized and graded, totals ~$543.1B across ten priced commitments out of fourteen (census of 2026-09-14; a program total, not unique obligations): $64B FILED across two filings naming Anthropic PBC - the TeraWulf 8-K lease ($19B firm rent, 20yr/401MW at the former Century Aluminum smelter site, rent on phased delivery from late 2027) and SpaceX's 424(b)(4) ($45B in filed CANCELLABLE terms: $1.25B/mo through May 2029, ~325K GPUs, 90-day mutual exit after month 3) - $180B company-confirmed, $299.1B press-grade (Riot included: dollars landlord-stated, tenant named only by reporting; a row grades by its weakest element); backed floor $244B; evidence quality inverse to headline size (Google ~$200B, the largest line, never stated by any party); Series H bought 6.7% at $965B post (65/965), last company-written revenue $47B (May, the round post itself) vs relay-carried $65B (end-July); zero issuer Form Ds behind the $65B raise (111 vehicle filings, re-run Sep 14); the federal arc: $200M CDAO ceiling Jul 2025, Pentagon work terminated + supply-chain-risk designation Feb 2026, OneGov terminated, two lawsuits Mar 9, the Aug 27 ruling vacating the designation as unlawful retaliation (appeal expected); every published tally reconciled in-piece (ValueAdd $275B+ / Decoding Discontinuity $254B-~$450B / The Information ~$517B: gaps are scope and vintage, not fact). Falsifier: The public S-1's audited compute-commitments note and revenue line: if filed+company commitments print materially below ~$244B, or audited run-rate prints materially below the relay-carried $65B end-July figure (last company-written: $47B, May), the tier census or the trail was wrong; the napkin (65/965 = 6.7%) fails only if the round's actual post-money differs from the company's stated $965B; the risk factors grade against the pre-disclosure record (the Aug 6 congressional letter, the Aug 27 ruling, the essay's committed evaluator names); the designation litigation (appeal + D.C. companion) runs to the listing. resolve by 2026-12-05 | pending |
| memory | memory-after-the-sold-out-years 2026-09-10 | Inside the memory oligopoly the post-2027 scaling paths diverged: Samsung committed the first High NA memory insertion (DRAM HVM by 2028), SK hynix hedges with one High NA tool plus a fleet-doubling 0.33NA order (KRW 11.95T), and Micron made no High NA commitment at all - while the Chinese challengers legally cannot buy EUV at any price and the next mask standard is being set without them. Falsifier: Micron announces High NA production insertion before 2028 (fork collapses into a rush); Samsung's 2028 date slides toward 2030 without comment (positioning, not commitment); memory cell design stalls or 3D stacking accelerates (High NA loses purpose for memory); AI capex rolls over (fork inverts into an over-investment contest); the 2027 HBM contract round clears materially below the +50-140% forecasts (demand-crack wins, insertion dates slip). resolve by 2027-06-30 | pending |
| nscale | nscale-103-billion-claimed-21-million 2026-09-07 | Nscale tells IPO investors ~$103B in contracted revenue against ~$100M a quarter (bookings or revenue, the relays do not say); the named deals sum to ~$51B (the August figure), leaving ~$52B with no named counterparty; the only audited lines anywhere in the group are ~$21M FY2024 (Norwegian, KPMG); Aker's equity-method note expects results near administrative expenses through the development phase Falsifier: FY2025 accounts (due 30 Sep 2026) and/or the S-1 show booked revenue ramping toward the ~$18B annualized contracted claim - or they do not; Aker's next carrying-value note is the second test resolve by 2026-12-31 | confirmed Resolved early by the S-1 (filed 2026-09-18, eleven days after publication). The fork held at filing grade on both sides: TCV $103.4B active+contracted filed take-or-pay vs the $103B investor-doc claim; audited revenue $19.1M FY2024 / $33.0M FY2025 / $140.6M H1-2026. The piece ~$21M FY2024 was the NOK census approximation of the audited $19.1M, corrected in place 2026-09-19. The unnamed $52B resolved to Microsoft (~$43.8B SOWs through 2033); concentration filed sharper (MSFT+Anthropic 86% of TCV). Ramp test: H1-2026 annualizes ~$281M vs the ~$18B implied - direction arrived, magnitude did not; RPO $34.5B recognition is the standing watch. Aker Q3 carrying note pending (corroborative; Q2 carried at the $14.6B Series C post). |
| two_stacks | two-stacks-the-ai-compute-supply 2026-08-26 | Both AI compute stacks converge at one chokepoint: every advanced-node path in the Western graph routes through ASML's sole-source EUV, which itself depends on two sole-source German suppliers (Trumpf lasers, Zeiss SMT optics). The chain narrows as it deepens - 23 direct NVIDIA dependents, 13 TSMC dependents, 1 EUV supplier, 2 tool suppliers - and the newest cross-stack evidence (Xiaomi's XRING self-sufficiency chips all fabricated by TSMC) deepened the dependency rather than thinning it. Falsifier: Volume Chinese sub-7nm production without ASML-serviced DUV (SMIC 5nm-class at yield), a Chinese EUV-class scanner in production use, or a Western frontier training run booting at scale on zero TSMC-fabricated accelerators; also refuted in part if the graph-derived counts (23 NVIDIA / 13 TSMC / 1 ASML / 2 German suppliers) fail re-derivation as the graph evolves. resolve by 2026-11-26 | pending |
| etched | etched-the-29-percent-round 2026-08-18 | Etched's $300M Series C at a claimed $10.3B post-money bought the entire syndicate roughly 2.9% of the company - the thinnest new-money slice of the 2026 AI-silicon set, at the only company in that set with no shipped product. The percentage is arithmetic against the company's own round figures; the valuation is a claim. Falsifier: A disclosed cap table, share count, or next-round/IPO filing showing the C syndicate's new-money stake materially above ~3%, or round economics (e.g. a large secondary component) that overturn the napkin. Post-publication datapoint already on record: the Aug 19 $700M Series D at $21B (a sibling 3.3% napkin), resolution judgment reserved to the operator. resolve by 2026-11-18 | pending |